Tripp Families of North America

Suzanna Griffin

Female 1831 - 1898  (67 years)


Generations:      Standard    |    Compact    |    Vertical    |    Text    |    Register    |    Tables    |    PDF

Generation: 1

  1. 1.  Suzanna Griffin was born on 14 July 1831 in New York, USA; died on 8 August 1898.

    Family/Spouse: Lewis Judah McIntosh. Lewis was born on 27 Oct 1821 in New York, USA; died on 18 April 1890 in Ashford, New York, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 2. Alice Adeline McIntosh  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 15 Jan 1852 in Cattaraugus County, New York, USA; died on 17 Jun 1913 in North Warren, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Youngsville, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA.


Generation: 2

  1. 2.  Alice Adeline McIntosh Descendancy chart to this point (1.Suzanna1) was born on 15 Jan 1852 in Cattaraugus County, New York, USA; died on 17 Jun 1913 in North Warren, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Youngsville, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA.

    Alice married Theodore Henry Tripp on 3 Jan 1873 in Saratoga County, New York, USA. Theodore (son of Ira A Tripp and Elizabeth McIntosh) was born on 25 Nov 1851 in Ballston Spa, Saratoga, New York, USA; died on 9 Jun 1914 in Brokenstraw, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Youngsville, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 3. Ida N Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on Abt. Nov 1873 in Milton, Saratoga, New York, USA; died on 7 May 1914 in Idaho Springs, Clear Creek, Colorado, USA.
    2. 4. Louis Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born about Apr 1875 in Milton, Saratoga, New York, USA; died on Aft. Jun 1875 in Saratoga County, New York, USA.
    3. 5. Fred Theodore Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 17 May 1875 in Ballston Spa, Saratoga, New York, USA; died on 19 Nov 1930 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA; was buried on 22 Nov 1930.
    4. 6. Jennie S Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 26 Aug 1878 in Cattaraugus County, New York, USA; died on 12 Mar 1939 in Kalkaska, Kalkaska, Michigan, USA; was buried in Youngsville, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA.
    5. 7. Luica\Luiece Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 23 Feb 1880 in Ballston Spa, Saratoga, New York, USA; died on 12 Jun 1880 in Ballston Spa, Saratoga, New York, USA.
    6. 8. Lydia Nancy Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 11 Nov 1883 in Springville, Erie, New York, USA; died on 24 Jun 1949 in Kalkaska, Kalkaska, Michigan, USA; was buried in Mio, Oscoda, Michigan, USA.
    7. 9. Flossie Mary Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 6 Apr 1889 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA; died on 16 Dec 1961 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Lafayette, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA.


Generation: 3

  1. 3.  Ida N Tripp Descendancy chart to this point (2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on Abt. Nov 1873 in Milton, Saratoga, New York, USA; died on 7 May 1914 in Idaho Springs, Clear Creek, Colorado, USA.

  2. 4.  Louis Tripp Descendancy chart to this point (2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born about Apr 1875 in Milton, Saratoga, New York, USA; died on Aft. Jun 1875 in Saratoga County, New York, USA.

  3. 5.  Fred Theodore Tripp Descendancy chart to this point (2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 17 May 1875 in Ballston Spa, Saratoga, New York, USA; died on 19 Nov 1930 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA; was buried on 22 Nov 1930.

    Fred married Bertha M Krebbel in Abt. 1897. Bertha (daughter of Carl Augustus Krebbel and Bertha Wilhelmina Tugendreich Frick) was born in Oct 1878 in Pennsylvania, USA; died on 18 Oct 1945 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 10. Jeanette M Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 15 Apr 1898 in Rockport, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 25 Sep 1924 in Chicago, Cook, Illinois, USA; was buried in Chicago, Cook, Illinois, USA.
    2. 11. William S Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 13 May 1902 in Bradford County, Pennsylvania, USA; died in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA.
    3. 12. Margaret Helen Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 14 Apr 1914 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA; died on 13 Dec 1991.

  4. 6.  Jennie S Tripp Descendancy chart to this point (2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 26 Aug 1878 in Cattaraugus County, New York, USA; died on 12 Mar 1939 in Kalkaska, Kalkaska, Michigan, USA; was buried in Youngsville, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA.

    Jennie married George F Shaw in 1895. George was born in Oct 1874 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 13. Clayton Franklin Shaw  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 15 Apr 1896 in McKean County, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 27 Dec 1917 in Youngsville, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Youngsville, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA.
    2. 14. Robert Louis Shaw  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 9 Feb 1902 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 31 Mar 1981 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA.
    3. 15. Infant girl Shaw  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 1 Feb 1914 in Youngsville, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 1 Feb 1914 in Youngsville, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA.

    Family/Spouse: Francis Dunham. Francis was born about 1882 in Michigan, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]


  5. 7.  Luica\Luiece Tripp Descendancy chart to this point (2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 23 Feb 1880 in Ballston Spa, Saratoga, New York, USA; died on 12 Jun 1880 in Ballston Spa, Saratoga, New York, USA.

  6. 8.  Lydia Nancy Tripp Descendancy chart to this point (2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 11 Nov 1883 in Springville, Erie, New York, USA; died on 24 Jun 1949 in Kalkaska, Kalkaska, Michigan, USA; was buried in Mio, Oscoda, Michigan, USA.

    Lydia married Frank Burnett L Williams in Abt. 1901. Frank was born on 18 Jan 1880 in Perry, Wyoming, New York, USA; died on 12 Jan 1956 in Michigan, USA; was buried in Mio, Oscoda County, Michigan, United States of America. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 16. Ida Ruth Williams  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 6 Jul 1902 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 23 Feb 1937 in Pontiac, Oakland, Michigan, USA.
    2. 17. Mildred A Williams  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 19 Dec 1903 in Pennsylvania, USA; died on 7 May 1992 in Los Angeles County, California, USA.

  7. 9.  Flossie Mary Tripp Descendancy chart to this point (2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 6 Apr 1889 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA; died on 16 Dec 1961 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Lafayette, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA.

    Flossie married William Woodford Vandermark on 24 Dec 1906 in Jamestown, Chautauqua, New York, USA. William was born on 16 May 1887 in Richford, Tioga, New York, USA; died on 14 Dec 1964 in Sayre, Bradford, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Union Center, Broome County, New York, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 18. Mabel Adell Vandermark  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 22 June 1909 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 2 Feb 1958 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA.
    2. 19. Rhea Alice Vandermark  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 2 Jul 1910 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 4 Oct 1997 in Manassas, Virginia, USA; was buried in Lafayette, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA.
    3. 20. Lester Earl Vandermark, Sr.  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 14 Feb 1914 in Mead, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 7 Jan 1965 in Berwick, Adams, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Lafayette, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA.
    4. 21. Beulah Mae Vandermark  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 2 Jan 1917 in Harrisburg, Dauphin, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 9 Aug 1995.

    Flossie married Franklin W Willibey on 5 May 1944 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA. Franklin was born about 1898 in Bradford County, Pennsylvania, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]



Generation: 4

  1. 10.  Jeanette M Tripp Descendancy chart to this point (5.Fred3, 2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 15 Apr 1898 in Rockport, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 25 Sep 1924 in Chicago, Cook, Illinois, USA; was buried in Chicago, Cook, Illinois, USA.

    Jeanette married Gordon Proctor on 25 Nov 1916 in Rochester, Monroe, New York, USA. Gordon (son of Simeon Proctor and Mary Ellen Hodgson) was born on 9 Nov 1895 in Rochester, Monroe, New York, USA; was christened on 2 Feb 1896 in Church of the Epiphany, Gates, New York, USA; died on 23 Feb 1952 in Attica, Genesee, New York, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Family/Spouse: Clement Hodgson. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]


  2. 11.  William S Tripp Descendancy chart to this point (5.Fred3, 2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 13 May 1902 in Bradford County, Pennsylvania, USA; died in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA.

    William married Gertrude E Davis on 26 Mar 1923 in Lackawanna, Erie, New York, USA. Gertrude (daughter of Henry Davis, Jr and Gertrude Neiman) was born on 14 Jun 1901 in Pennsylvania, USA; died on 8 Aug 1961; was buried in Cheektowaga, Erie, New York, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 22. William A Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 22 Mar 1924 in Lackawanna, Erie, New York, USA; died on 30 May 1948 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA.
    2. 23. Margaret J Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 20 Nov 1926 in Lackawanna, Erie, New York, USA.
    3. 24. Bertie Lou Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born about 1929 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA.
    4. 25. Hilda Anita Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 7 Jan 1930 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA; died on 26 Oct 2006.
    5. 26. Charles Raymond Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 16 Mar 1931 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA; died on 25 Apr 1997; was buried in West Seneca, Erie, New York, USA.
    6. 27. Vonette V Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 24 Feb 1933 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA; died in 2014; was buried in Dunkirk, Chautauqua, New York, USA.
    7. 28. Violet M Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 1 Jul 1934 in Sardinia, Erie, New York, USA; died on 7 Feb 2010 in Dunkirk, Chautauqua, New York, USA; was buried in Dunkirk, Chautauqua, New York, USA.
    8. 29. Donald O Tripp  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 16 Jan 1938 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA; died on 7 Jul 2012.

  3. 12.  Margaret Helen Tripp Descendancy chart to this point (5.Fred3, 2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 14 Apr 1914 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA; died on 13 Dec 1991.

    Margaret married Lester Earl Vandermark, Sr. on 2 Aug 1932 in Olean, Cattaraugus, New York, USA. Lester (son of William Woodford Vandermark and Flossie Mary Tripp) was born on 14 Feb 1914 in Mead, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 7 Jan 1965 in Berwick, Adams, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Lafayette, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 30. Lester Vandermark, Jr.  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 9 Aug 1933 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA; died on 20 Sep 1949 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA.

    Margaret married Fred Zierk on 3 Jun 1939 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA. Fred was born on 22 Feb 1902. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Margaret married _____ Moll in 1942. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Margaret married _____ Reinacher in 1948. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Margaret married _____ Brown in 1974. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]


  4. 13.  Clayton Franklin Shaw Descendancy chart to this point (6.Jennie3, 2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 15 Apr 1896 in McKean County, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 27 Dec 1917 in Youngsville, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Youngsville, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA.

  5. 14.  Robert Louis Shaw Descendancy chart to this point (6.Jennie3, 2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 9 Feb 1902 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 31 Mar 1981 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA.

    Robert married Josephine Marie Arrowsmith on 29 Jun 1927 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA. Josephine was born about 1902 in Pennsylvania, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]


  6. 15.  Infant girl Shaw Descendancy chart to this point (6.Jennie3, 2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 1 Feb 1914 in Youngsville, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 1 Feb 1914 in Youngsville, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA.

  7. 16.  Ida Ruth Williams Descendancy chart to this point (8.Lydia3, 2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 6 Jul 1902 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 23 Feb 1937 in Pontiac, Oakland, Michigan, USA.

    Ida married Frank Howard Edgerton on 6 Oct 1921 in Redford, Wayne, Michigan, USA. Frank was born on 25 Feb 1897 in Bridgeport, Madison, New York, USA; died on 21 Jul 1972 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 31. Thelma R Edgerton  Descendancy chart to this point was born about 1925 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA.
    2. 32. William Howard Edgerton  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 8 May 1927 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA; died on 25 Sep 1997 in Los Angeles County, California, USA.
    3. 33. Shirley Louise Edgerton  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 24 Jun 1929 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA; died in Sep 1998.

  8. 17.  Mildred A Williams Descendancy chart to this point (8.Lydia3, 2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 19 Dec 1903 in Pennsylvania, USA; died on 7 May 1992 in Los Angeles County, California, USA.

    Mildred married James N Streeter on 9 Sep 1920 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA, and was divorced on 30 Sep 1927 in Wayne County, Michigan, USA. James was born about 1891. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 34. Drusilla Nancy Streeter  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 20 Feb 1923 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA; died on 4 May 1995.

    Mildred married James Edgar Cross on 1 Oct 1927 in Lucas County, Ohio, USA. James (son of William Benjamin Cross and Sarah Ann Heffley) was born on 25 Dec 1890 in Pennsylvania, USA; died on 31 May 1967 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA; was buried in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 35. Edgar J Cross  Descendancy chart to this point was born about 1919 in Pennsylvania, USA.
    2. 36. Mary Ann Cross Whaley  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 17 Jan 1922 in Detroit, Wayne, Michigan, USA; died on 15 Jun 2014 in Cincinnati, Hamilton, Ohio, USA; was buried in Ross, Butler, Ohio, USA.
    3. 37. Barbara M Cross  Descendancy chart to this point was born about 1928 in Michigan, USA.
    4. 38. Allen Burnett Cross  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 13 Nov 1930 in Grosse Pointe, Wayne, Michigan, USA; died on 6 Sep 1998.
    5. 39. Living  Descendancy chart to this point

  9. 18.  Mabel Adell Vandermark Descendancy chart to this point (9.Flossie3, 2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 22 June 1909 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 2 Feb 1958 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA.

    Mabel married Lynn Sidelinger on 6 Nov 1925 in Salamanca, Cattaraugus, New York, USA. Lynn was born on 7 Jul 1905 in Brockport, Elk, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 16 Oct 1988 in Athens, Bradford, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Cortland, Cortland, New York, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 40. Lynn Marvin Sidelinger  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 21 Feb 1928 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 31 Jan 1997; was buried in Cortland, Cortland, New York, USA.
    2. 41. Robert Mer Sidelinger  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 1 Mar 1929 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 11 Dec 1929 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA.

    Family/Spouse: Ross McAlpine. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]


  10. 19.  Rhea Alice Vandermark Descendancy chart to this point (9.Flossie3, 2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 2 Jul 1910 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 4 Oct 1997 in Manassas, Virginia, USA; was buried in Lafayette, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA.

    Rhea married Fred Roberts in Abt. 1929. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 42. Richard Joseph Roberts  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 4 Dec 1931 in Hornell, Steuben, New York, USA; was buried in Four Mile Fork, Spotsylvania County, Virginia, USA.
    2. 43. Living  Descendancy chart to this point
    3. 44. Living  Descendancy chart to this point

    Rhea married Earl Leon Erskin, Jr. on 11 Aug 1945 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA. Earl (son of Earl Leon Erskin) was born on 8 Aug 1907 in Eldred, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 9 Apr 1947 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Lafayette, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 45. Hazel Mae Erskin  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 26 Jul 1946 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 23 Jun 1959 in Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Lafayette, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA.
    2. 46. Harriet Erskin  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 26 Jul 1946 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 26 Jul 1946 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA.

    Rhea married Robert Monroe Brocious in Abt. 1949 in Pennsylvania, USA. Robert was born on 28 Mar 1911 in Pennsylvania, USA; died in Mar 1982. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Family/Spouse: Dewitt Gray. Dewitt was born in Abt. 1897 in Pennsylvania, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 47. Fred Raymond Gray  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 30 Jan 1927 in Bradford McKean, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 7 Nov 1985 in Lawndale, Los Angeles, California, USA; was buried in Rancho Palos Verdes, Los Angeles, California, USA.

  11. 20.  Lester Earl Vandermark, Sr. Descendancy chart to this point (9.Flossie3, 2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 14 Feb 1914 in Mead, Warren, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 7 Jan 1965 in Berwick, Adams, Pennsylvania, USA; was buried in Lafayette, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA.

    Lester married Margaret Helen Tripp on 2 Aug 1932 in Olean, Cattaraugus, New York, USA. Margaret (daughter of Fred Theodore Tripp and Bertha M Krebbel) was born on 14 Apr 1914 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA; died on 13 Dec 1991. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 30. Lester Vandermark, Jr.  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 9 Aug 1933 in Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA; died on 20 Sep 1949 in Bradford, McKean, Pennsylvania, USA.

    Family/Spouse: Geraldine (-) Vandermark. Geraldine was born about 1923 in Pennsylvania. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 48. Living  Descendancy chart to this point
    2. 49. Living  Descendancy chart to this point
    3. 50. Living  Descendancy chart to this point

  12. 21.  Beulah Mae Vandermark Descendancy chart to this point (9.Flossie3, 2.Alice2, 1.Suzanna1) was born on 2 Jan 1917 in Harrisburg, Dauphin, Pennsylvania, USA; died on 9 Aug 1995.

    Beulah married John Francis O'Brien on 7 Sep 1935 in Norwich, Chenango, New York, USA, and was divorced on 13 Apr 1944 in Wayne County, Michigan, USA. John was born on 27 Sep 1912 in Cortland County, New York, USA; died in Jun 1974. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 51. James Francis O'Brien  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 28 Apr 1936 in Cortland, Cortland, New York, USA; died on 28 Apr 1997; was buried in Bethlehem, Northampton, Pennsylvania, USA.
    2. 52. Robert Edward O'Brien  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 26 Jul 1937 in Cortland County, New York, USA; died in May 1985.
    3. 53. Richard C O'Brien  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 16 Jul 1938 in Cortland County, New York, USA; died on 4 Dec 2022; was buried on 9 Dec 2023 in Cortland County, New York, USA.

    Family/Spouse: Henry Alexander. Henry was born on 20 Nov 1909 in New York, USA; died on 27 Jan 1985; was buried in Fort Pierce, St. Lucie County, Florida, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 51. James Francis O'Brien  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 28 Apr 1936 in Cortland, Cortland, New York, USA; died on 28 Apr 1997; was buried in Bethlehem, Northampton, Pennsylvania, USA.
    2. 54. Living  Descendancy chart to this point